According to the content of the verdict, Ms. THH must be responsible for handing over to her younger brother, Mr. TTM, to manage and use 155.3 square meters of residential land and garden land in Viet Hoa ward (Hai Duong city).
On the morning of March 18, the Civil Judgment Enforcement Department of Hai Duong province organized the enforcement of the judgment against Ms. THH in Viet Hoa ward (Hai Duong city) in the transfer of land use rights to Mr. TTM.
The enforcement is carried out according to the first instance civil judgment of the People's Court of Hai Duong province in September 2022 and the decision to suspend the appeal trial of the civil case of the High People's Court in Hanoi in October 2023; according to the enforcement decisions of the Enforcement Officer of the Provincial Civil Judgment Enforcement Department in February 2025.
According to the verdict, Ms. H. and Mr. M. are biological sisters. Ms. H. and Mr. M.'s parents had 6 children and shared 2 plots of land in Viet Hoa ward (Hai Duong city).
The parents of Ms. H. and Mr. M. (deceased) left a will to 2 of their 6 children, giving them a plot of land.
For the remaining plot of land, Ms. H. self-declared and applied for a land use right certificate and was granted the certificate in August 2003.
According to the court, Ms. H. claimed that her parents had a will leaving her the above plot of land but could not provide a copy of the will as required by law; only a photocopy of the power of attorney was provided so there was no basis for determination.
A representative of Hai Duong City People's Committee confirmed that the file to issue a land use right certificate to Ms. H. is currently not stored in the archives of the City Land Use Right Registration Office.
The Court decided that Ms. H. is responsible for handing over to Mr. M. the management and use of 155.3 square meters of residential land and garden land from the land left by her parents in Viet Hoa ward and the assets on the land. Mr. M. must return the value of Ms. H.'s assets on the land given to Mr. M., which is more than 43 million VND.
Ms. H. has the right to manage and use the area of 290.5 m2 and the assets on the land, and is responsible for paying the difference to Mr. M. of more than 1 billion VND.
The court accepted the voluntary donation.Inheriting the property is the land use rights of the siblings to Mr. M.; accepting the voluntary refusal of Mrs. D. (sister of Mr. M. and Mrs. H.) to inherit the property.
The bailiff has worked with Ms. H. many times, but Ms. H. has not voluntarily executed the judgment.
Enforcement is carried out in accordance with requirements, regulations and safety.
NT